Score: 4

"confuse"

submission: Zelda Metalized

date: April 24, 2009

Good idea but really too confused to be enjoyable (too much reverb, wrong volumes, and discordant notes here and there)

Score: 8

"great atmosphere"

submission: Washed away

date: April 21, 2009

I like the way it flows and the atmosphere it creates (a bit Enigma and a bit Vangelis)
And the sounds blends together in a perfect way... congrats for your work! :)
It's also quite spontaneous as a song, and this is a good thing in my point of view.
(I think the piano sometimes makes something harmonically incorrect, like for example around 1:35, but maybe it's just me...)

Score: 7

"nice atmosphere... needs some refining"

submission: Nightmare's Lair

date: October 16, 2008

I really like the atmosphere you created here (love the bass and the laugh).
Anyway I think it needs some refining, a better mix and more space-feeling (it sounds like there is no space for the sounds and the instruments... try add a bit of reverb).

Score: 7

"waiting for a better version..."

submission: Hymn For The Fallen

date: October 16, 2008

Interesting but, as already said by the other reviewers, it needs much refining.
As it is, it's worth a 6... but I'm giving you 7 as an incentive :)

The atmosphere is here, some sounds are great, but it needs a very better mix. And try to make the choirs and the strings more realistic... (some higher voices are very annoying), so don't abuse of the samples' extension.